MLB Betting Picks & Predictions
Baseball gives us a new betting board almost every day of the season. Our MLB picks focus on the matchups where the starting pitchers, bullpens, lineups or available odds give us something worth digging into, from full-game bets to First 5 innings and player props.
Today’s MLB Picks
A busy MLB schedule can mean 15 games and hundreds of available bets, but we’re not interested in filling the page with picks just because the markets are there.
Below are the bets that made our card today. The number will vary from one slate to the next, and we’ll sometimes wait for confirmed lineups or weather information before adding a selection.
-
Tampa Bay Rays at New York Yankees: Tuesday’s quiet bats have pushed this total too low
Tampa Bay Rays at New York Yankees
Over +6.5 Total / -106 WonTuesday’s doubleheader produced only nine runs across two games, but recent starter form leaves more scoring paths than the new total implies.
Read prediction -
Pittsburgh Pirates at Chicago White Sox: Chicago’s bullpen plan lowers the scoring ceiling
Pittsburgh Pirates at Chicago White Sox
Under +8 Total / -115 WonChicago’s relief depth changes how to price a bullpen game, while Jones arrives off six scoreless innings. The total of eight provides useful protection.
Read prediction
How Our MLB Picks Have Performed
There’s no reason to judge a baseball betting record only by its best days. Once we’ve published a pick, it remains part of our results.
Picks record
Results: 2 won · 0 lost · 0 pushed
Based on published, settled picks. Pushes are excluded from win rate.
What We Look at Before Betting an MLB Game
The starting pitcher is the obvious place to begin, but treating baseball as a simple comparison between two starters misses a large part of the game.
We want to know how each pitcher matches up with the opposing lineup. A right-handed starter can face a very different challenge against a lineup loaded with productive left-handed bats, while strikeout rates, walks, ground balls and home-run tendencies can all influence which market interests us.
Then there is everything that happens after the starter leaves. Bullpen availability matters throughout a 162-game season. If a team’s best relievers worked heavily the night before, we may view its full-game moneyline differently from its First 5 innings line. That distinction is one reason baseball gives us more ways to approach a matchup than simply picking a winner.
We don’t give every factor the same weight in every game. A strong wind at Wrigley can be highly relevant to a total, while bullpen usage may be much less important if we’re betting only the first five innings.
Different Ways We Bet Baseball
One reason we like MLB from a betting perspective is that a good read on a matchup doesn’t have to translate into the same type of bet every time.
MLB Moneyline Picks
The moneyline is a bet on which team wins the game. Instead of asking only which team is better, we look at whether the available price properly reflects the pitching matchup, lineup and likely bullpen situation.
A team can be our expected winner without being our bet. If the moneyline is too expensive, we’ll look elsewhere or leave the game alone.
First 5 Innings Picks
First 5 betting lets us concentrate more heavily on the starting pitchers and reduce the influence of the bullpens later in the game.
Suppose we like one starter considerably more than the other but don’t trust his team’s relief pitching. The First 5 moneyline or run line may fit our view of the matchup better than betting the same team over nine innings. That makes First 5 one of the MLB markets we pay particular attention to.
MLB Run Line Picks
The standard run line is usually 1.5 runs. Backing a favorite at -1.5 means it needs to win by at least two runs, while an underdog at +1.5 can lose by one and still cover.
We may consider the run line when we like a favorite but don’t want to pay a short moneyline price. How a team’s offense, bullpen and expected game script fit the bet matters here because simply winning isn’t enough.
MLB Over/Under Picks
For totals, pitching is only part of the equation. We also look at the opposing offenses, bullpen depth, ballpark and weather.
Baseball is unusually sensitive to playing conditions. Wind direction, temperature and the dimensions of the stadium can change the environment considerably, so the same pitching matchup won’t necessarily produce the same outlook in every ballpark.
NRFI & YRFI Picks
NRFI means No Run First Inning, while YRFI means Yes Run First Inning. Instead of betting on the entire game, we’re predicting whether either team will score in the opening inning.
These bets make the top of each batting order particularly important. We consider the two starters, how they tend to begin games and the hitters they’re likely to face in the first inning before deciding whether the sportsbook’s price interests us.
MLB Player Prop Picks
Pitcher strikeouts are one of the MLB prop markets we follow closely. A strikeout line can depend on much more than whether a pitcher is considered good or bad, with the opposing lineup’s strikeout tendencies, expected pitch count and how deep he’s likely to work all playing a part.
For hitters, we can look at markets such as hits, total bases, home runs and RBIs. Batting order position, handedness matchup and ballpark are among the factors that can change our view of those lines.
Why the Bullpen Can Change the Bet
That can create an important distinction between betting the whole game and betting the First 5. We may like the starter enough to back his team early without wanting to rely on the relievers expected to follow him. It’s something we check each day rather than relying on a season-long bullpen ranking.
Finding the Right Line for an MLB Pick
Shopping around matters in baseball because sportsbooks can disagree on more than price. One book may have a pitcher at 5.5 strikeouts while another has already moved to 6.5. First 5 lines, run lines and hitter props can also vary.
Before placing one of our picks, check whether the line you’re getting is still comparable to the one shown with our selection. Our guide to baseball betting sites can also help you compare sportsbooks for MLB markets, props and live betting.